Didn't Mayoral Control "Work" in New York City?

No. Some of its strongest advocates in NYC now oppose it. Others, who support it in NYC, caution against it in mid-sized cities with strong traditions of elected school board, which NYC does not have (prior to Mayoral Control in NYC, Borough Presidents appointed boards -- its a ridiculous comparison). Dr. Cala's essay easily debunks the assertion about NYC, pointing out how special "exit codes" were established to count "disappeared" NYC students off the books, and pad "Graduation Rates." If you can't access a copy of Cala's essay on line, contact me, and I will get you a copy.

The plain fact of the matter is that urban school districts with best graduation rates are NOT Mayoral Control districts. For Rochester's track record with politically appointed boards like proposed, you need look no further than recent Water Authority scandals and the MCC leadership search gong show.